Specifics on the dangers of Satellite being implemented as a primary broadband solution consideration include:
LEO (Low Earth Orbit) Satellite SPEED/PERFORMANCE LIMITATIONS
Slower Performance with More Users: Fiber offers scalable infrastructure, while satellite bandwidth is finite. As more users connect to a given satellite network, speeds drop.
Insufficient Upload Speeds: Starlink reports average upload speeds of 5 to 20 Mbps, below what is necessary for modern broadband applications. In contrast, major ISPs offer plans with symmetrical gigabit or multi-gigabit speeds. Satellite speeds are also affected by the number of individuals connected to a satellite network, and atmospheric conditions.
Weather Vulnerability and Service Interruptions: Fiber is largely immune to weather-related disruptions (especially if it is deployed underground through conduit), satellite signals degrade in bad weather. A critical issue for users who rely on internet service for work, education, and emergency services.
Long-Term Cost Inefficiency: Fiber is a one-time infrastructure investment with decades of lifespan. Starlink satellites have a short lifespan of approximately five years, requiring continuous spending on launches, maintenance, and user equipment upgrades just to keep the current service running.
Risk of Monopoly / Limited Competition: Starlink has a first-mover advantage, raising concerns about monopolistic control over satellite broadband. The BEAD program rules do not currently consider LEO a reliable broadband service. If NTIA changes the definition of “reliable broadband service” , states may award Starlink many more locations. This could entrench Starlink and risk monopolizing the industry's development.
Lack of quality jobs: Satellite employs fewer workers, and there are currently no union-represented LEO satellite internet providers.
Space debris, collisions, and light pollution: Starlink’s goal of placing 42,000 LEO satellites in orbit increases space debris and increases the risk of collision with other satellites or space missions.
Please share the attached flyer and petition with your membership. For questions please contact, Marcus Chambers, CWA Maryland Broadband Brigade Lead, mchambers@cwa-2107.org.
OR
Visit: https://action.cwa.org/petitions/we-need-reliable-internet-service-and-good-jobs?source=flyer
_____________________________
MARYLAND STATE AND D.C.
AFL-CIO
Donna S. Edwards
President
Gerald W. Jackson
Secretary Treasurer
7 School Street | Annapolis, MD 21401 |
Phone: (410) 280-2233 | Fax: (410) 280-2956